Opinion: Derail the Bullet Train, Fix the Water Supply!

Transit experts worldwide have concluded there is no way California's High Speed Rail project can survive without taxpayer support.

California voters have a golden opportunity to do something they seldom get to do- correct a colossal mistake before it gets too far down the line to fix easily.

By now, many, if not most, voters who approved the California High Speed Rail Proposition (Prop 1A) in 2008 realize they were sold a $98 BILLION bill of goods.

It’s becoming ever more apparent every day that we, the voters, were simply lied to during that campaign.

We were told that there was no way the train plan would ever consume a penny of taxpayer money. Now, transit experts worldwide have concluded there is NO way the bullet train can survive WITHOUT taxpayer support.

We were told that private enterprise would jump up and fight for the chance to invest in the high speed rail concept- now, we are seeing that NO ONE in the private sector is the least bit interested in investing, unless there ARE substantial revenue guarantees from the state.

“Revenue guarantees” commonly goes by another name: taxpayer subsidies.

There are credible people saying the train supporters knew this from the start and didn’t tell us the truth about it.

To their credit, Republican House members in Washington D.C. are calling for all federal funding for this train wreck to be halted, and they’re running into severe blowback from the Obama administration, which sees the bullet train as the wave of the future.

The federal funding cuts may work, but they may not. The concept of a “bullet train” is a sexy concept for Republicans who like to build lots of things everywhere.

That’s why it’s way past time for the voters of California to stop this thing themselves.

Bear in mind that the legislature, stampeded by bullet train high priest Jerry Brown, has committed $6 BILLION dollars to build the first link of the train.

I don’t know about you, but I wouldn’t pay $6 to ride from San Fernando to Merced- I certainly wouldn’t pay $6 billion.

What needs to happen is for citizens to band together and form a grass roots movement to qualify a measure for the 2014 ballot, rescinding the previous approval of Prop. 1A.

Tell Sacramento and Washington that we now know the truth about the “bullet”train , and we want our money back.

If we want to spend money on something that WILL do us some good, we should link that rescission measure to another ballot measure for 2014- an $11 billion measure that would seriously upgrade and improve our state water system.

That is something we need badly, and something that will actually do all of us good.

Do I want my money spent on a travel system that will take me from San Diego to San Francisco much more slowly than Southwest Airlines can get me there- and much more expensively?

Or do I want a better guarantee that, when I turn on the tap in the morning, fresh clean water will flow, so I can have a drink of water?

To me, it’s not a hard choice to make.

Also read: Colorado River Water Shortage for Western States Foreseen in U.S. Study

Mark December 18, 2012 at 07:21 PM
Agreed - stop the train, fix the water.
Jon Hall December 18, 2012 at 07:32 PM
Too late --- it has already left the station --- and is on schedule --- coming to a tax bill near you ...
Doug Curlee December 18, 2012 at 10:31 PM
no, jon.. i don't think it is too late..the republicans in the house might be able to slow it down enough for the people of california to vote to stop it.. but that means that people in california need to get cracking on a full-on campaign to overturn 2008's proposition 1a.. time's a'wastin'.. doug
Jon Hall December 18, 2012 at 10:45 PM
Doug --- Moonbeam has a supermajority --- the people have already spoken --- and they gave the Progressives a green light for whatever they want to do ...
Ed Sorrels December 19, 2012 at 12:55 AM
Damn if it was only this easy !
Ed Sorrels December 19, 2012 at 01:19 AM
Doiug, It's like the old W.P.A. duriong the 30's, just a sham to provide job's up there in the valley. There is no concieveable use for the damn thing and it need's to be pitched in the rubbish can. Once it starts sucking at the public teet there will be no stopping it as their arguement will be a" Well we can't quit now and waste all that money' Question is why start it doesn't pencil out even with california math !
Doug Curlee December 19, 2012 at 01:46 AM
well, that's why the people have to stop it.. that's why i'm talking about a ballot measure..if the people band together and vote to overturn prop 1a, there won't be a damned thing the legislature can do about it.. doug
sheeple herder December 19, 2012 at 02:00 AM
Good luck, Doug... Thought you had been covering the government long enough to know if they want to do something, they'll do it. Hold secret meetings at night and pass laws, executive orders, town hall meetings they lead you to believe you have a voice at, etc... Didn't people vote on laws that were squashed by a few dictating to the majority of voters; ie homosexual "marriage", marijuana, maybe quail brush....? As well as this silver bullet to no-wheres-ville, if I remember correctly?
Doug Curlee December 19, 2012 at 03:20 AM
no.. we the voters, acting on bad information if not total lies, approved this mess.. and we the voters can overturn this mess.. oif a ballot measure passes reversing proposition 1a, there's not a thing the legislature can do about it.. they can hold all the secret meetings they want to..it'll do them no good..and this is the sort of measure the courts would be very loath to overturn.. we really need to do this.. doug
Erika Lowery December 19, 2012 at 05:51 AM
Doug, In all seriousness, I think the state should contract with the company running this line. I think *MAYBE* it might have a snowball's chance in Hades to be profitable. http://www.10news.com/news/train-from-socal-to-las-vegas-coming-soon-company-promises-nightclub-on-rails-experience-121812
Libi Uremovic December 19, 2012 at 09:46 PM
high speed rail from vegas to l.a. has been dead in the water for years because they can't get permission to go into orange or l.a. counties and no one is going to drive to san bernadino county then get on a train to vegas...
Libi Uremovic December 19, 2012 at 09:52 PM
i agree - kill high speed rail...it's not the time or the place... we don't have the money or immediate need for high speed ...and there will never be a need to the train to pass through the valley......the valley already has amtrac that's rarely used in that area... high speed rail going straight up the coast from san diego to frisco would make money from locals, tourists, businessmen ...but the state is going to have to have the balls to take the land along the west side of our coastal mountain range, not waste time and money laying track in the valley...
Doug Curlee December 19, 2012 at 09:53 PM
i wouldn't bet on that if i were you, libi.. people who want to get to vegas will do just about anything to get there..and i can edasily see a fleet of luxury buses or limos picking people up at home and taking them to the train..then taking them back home when they come back.. ANYTHING to avoid that drive!!! doug
Libi Uremovic December 19, 2012 at 10:02 PM
i lived in vegas when they were trying to push the train before the economic crash...they couldn't get private funding because they can't get the rail past san bernadino.... ....so harry reid played with the paperwork and got them double government funding...but it still didn't help because private sector can see that it's not going to make money if they can't get into l.a. ...


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »